Top 9 Best Shaving Soap For Men 2023

Introduction to the best Men’s shaving Soap

Are you trying to shave off your beard, but you have sensitive skin? Several grooming products might not work well with you since they might end up causing a lot of breakouts on your skin.

Fortunately, one of the grooming products for men from way back then is making a comeback. And for a good cause. Shaving soaps lubricate your face through its lather, allowing you to glide the razor across your skin without any irritation.

The best shaving soap for men is also very light and not that expensive.

Before diving into the best shaving soap for sensitive skin, you may find yourself asking how a shaving soap works.

When using shaving soap, you would need a shaving brush to create the lather for shaving. You first need to soak the brush in water and then swirl it over the soap’s surface. Afterwhich, apply the brush to your face to be lathered. Then you’re good to go.

Knowing how to use the shaving soap isn’t the end-all to it. You should learn to gauge what products are in and what products are not.

To help you with this, we have curated nine of the best shaving soaps for men. Please take a look at their pros and cons so you can better decipher the product to purchase.

Summary of the Top 9 Best Shaving Soap For Men 2023

No	Shave Soap Product Name	Key Feature
1	Proraso Shaving Soap In a Bowl – Refresh	Best shaving soap for a refreshed skin
2	The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap	Best shaving soap for skin protection
3	Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap	Best shaving soap with superb value
4	Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl – Sensitive Skin	best shaving soap for sensitive skin
5	D.R. Harris Almond Shaving Soap	Best shaving soap for a perfect shaving experience
6	Truefitt & Hill Luxury Shaving Soap	Best fragrant shaving soap
7	Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shaving Soap Refill	Best shaving soap for a soft skin
8	Taylor of Old Bond Cedarwood Shaving Cream	Best nourishing shaving soap
9	The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap Refill	Best shaving soap for a smooth skin

Top 9 Best Shave Soap For Men 2023 Review

1. Proraso Shaving Soap In a Bowl – Refresh

Kicking off our list of the best shaving soap for men is the Proraso Shaving Soap In a Bowl – Refresh. It has been designed to work on any beard of any man.

Refreshing

What we love about this shaving soap is it is, in fact, as its name implies, refreshing to the skin. It contains eucalyptus oil that tones and purifies your skin and facial hair.

The menthol component of this shaving soap, on the other hand, helps revitalize and refresh your skin. Hence, you get to have a cool feeling after you have shaved.

Softens the skin

Of course, this shaving soap is also as efficient as it is refreshing. It creates a rich lather that would soften the skin. This way, you can have a close shave without any cuts or nicks.

Pros 

• It provides a luxurious shave without bleeding.
• This shaving soap lathers well.
• The scent is not overpowering.

Cons

• It tends to break up into goopy lumps.
• It looks like a hard gel.

Where to Buy Proraso Shaving Soap In a Bowl – Refresh

2. The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap

For a more conventional wet-shave experience, you could opt for The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap. It is formulated with coconut oil and glycerin for an optimal shaving experience.

Strong Scent

This shaving soap has a uniquely masculine scent that has been crafted expertly. The aroma can be traced from the woody Indian sandalwood fragrance paired with lush and deep aromas to form this blend. Its woody undertone is both sensual yet calming at the same time.

Protects the Skin

What we also love about this shaving soap is that it helps protect the skin. It forms a rich lather that allows in gliding the razor and prevents cuts and irritation. The lather also softens the beard while offering a close shave.

Pros 

• The scent is topnotch.
• It creates a thick creamy lather.
• It is worth the money.

Con

• One has to work a little harder to get enough soap.

Where to Buy The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap

3. Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap

The Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap also makes it into our list. This is a high-quality British shave soap that is typically used with a shaving brush.

It comes in an attractive handcrafted acacia wood bowl. When the soap runs out, you can always purchase a refill and still use this bowl.

Fragrance

What makes this shaving soap a standout is its fragrance. It features a classic fougère smell with notes of geranium, lavender, liquid amber, and rosemary.

The fragrance is supported by carnation, fern, and orange blossom. All of these aromas rest on a base of patchouli sandalwood for a rich musky smell.

Cleanses the Skin

What makes this a standout shaving soap is that it can cleanse the skin while offering an excellent lather. 

Pros 

• The wooden bowl is beautiful.
• It provides a smooth, creamy lather.
• It works well for those with sensitive skin.

Cons

• The scent is too strong.
• The soap does not lather quickly.

Where to Buy Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap

4. Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl – Sensitive Skin

The next on our list is the Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl – Sensitive Skin. It creates a rich lather that protects and soothes your skin. Thanks to its creamy lather, you will avoid any burns or irritation.

For Sensitive Skin

What we love about this shaving soap is it is, in fact, as its name implies, for sensitive skin. It consists of green tea and oatmeal that help soothe and protect your sensitive skin. 

Made of Natural Ingredients

To even further help you protect your skin, this product contains no mineral oils or artificial colors. Instead, it consists of natural oils and nourishing botanical extracts to protect your skin throughout the shaving process for an irritation-free experience.

Pros 

• It is an excellent everyday shaving soap.
• This soap has great lather.
• It is an excellent everyday shaving soap.

Cons

• The scent changes.
• It does not soak into the brush.

Where to Buy Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl – Sensitive Skin

5. D.R. Harris Almond Shaving Soap

The D.R. Harris Almond Shaving Soap is known for its glossy, compact, and dense lather that does not require you to exert a lot of effort. 

Economical

Each of the shaving soaps is designed to last for several months. The bowl is made of sustainably sourced Sheesham wood with a mahogany effect. Since the wooden bowls are treated to last many years, you can simply buy refills for them.

Fine Quality

This shaving soap is also known for its stunning fragrance of dry almond. It has been triple-milled to form excellent lather and give you a great shaving experience.

Moreover, it helps lubricate and soften your beard to allow seamless shaving.

Pros 

• This shaving soap smells incredible.
• It lathers very well.

Cons

• It does not offer enough rehydration.
• It tends to smell different.

Where to Buy D.R. Harris Almond Shaving Soap

6. Truefitt & Hill Luxury Shaving Soap

We also think that the Truefitt & Hill Luxury Shaving Soap is one of the best shaving soaps for men. It comes in a hand-turned Acacia wood bowl, making it suitable for refills.

Great scent

This shaving soap has a fresh oceanic fragrance with notes of Mandarin, Bergamot, and Cardamon. Moreover, this soap is combined with Geranium, Lavender, and Clary Sage heart that rests on sandalwood, musk, and Cedarwood.

Rich lather

One of the best features of this shaving soap is its exquisite quality by providing you with a rich lather that delivers a smooth shave.

Pros 

• The smell of this shaving soap is excellent.
• It lathers very nicely.
• The slickness of the lather lasts longer.

Cons

• The lather is airy and weak.
• It does not smell like sandalwood.

Where to Buy Truefitt & Hill Luxury Shaving Soap

7. Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shaving Soap Refill

The following product on our list is Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shaving Soap Refill. While this is different from the other products, being just a refill compared to others with a container, this soap still delivers top-notch quality.

For sensitive skin

The soothing and gentle lather of this soap is suitable for those with sensitive skin. Thanks to its natural lanolin, you can keep your skin soft and smooth.

Great lather

What we also love about this product is that it creates lather, giving you the perfect shave.

Pros 

• It works well no matter what the skin type is.
• It leaves a moisturizing feel on the skin.

Cons

• The lather is thin.
• It tends to dissipate quickly.

Where to Buy Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shaving Soap Refill

8. Taylor of Old Bond Cedarwood Shaving Cream

The Taylor of Old Bond Cedarwood Shaving Cream offers excellent lather and masculine fragrance that you can enjoy.

Made of Natural Ingredients

What makes this product a standout is that it is made of natural ingredients that offer various benefits. Plantain extract is rich in Vitamin B complex. Yucca promotes hair growth for thicker, fuller hair.

On the other hand, Baobab oil contains Vitamins A, D, E, and F that fortify and strengthen your hair.

Great Lather

This is a good option because it has been designed to produce a rich and creamy lather.

Pros 

• It has a subtle, natural-smelling scent.
• The soap lubricates well.
• This shaving soap goes a long way.

Cons

• The smell is not that good.
• The soap tends to be dried out.

Where to Buy Taylor of Old Bond Cedarwood Shaving Cream

9. The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap Refill

Completing our list of the best shaving soap for men is The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap Refill. It is formulated with coconut oil and glycerin for an optimal shaving experience.

Protects the Skin

What we also love about this shaving soap is that it helps protect the skin. It forms a rich lather that allows in gliding the razor and prevents irritation.

There are no synthetic dyes and alcohols included in this soap, so you are ensured that your sensitive skin is well-protected.

Strong Scent

This shaving soap has a uniquely masculine scent that has been crafted expertly.

The aroma can be traced from the woody Indian sandalwood fragrance paired with lush and deep aromas to form this blend. Its woody undertone is both sensual yet calming at the same time.

Pros 

• It forms a thick creamy lather.
• This shaving soap is worth the money.

Cons

• It does not provide good enough lather.
• This shaving soap tends not to deliver a clean shave.

Where to Buy The Art of Shaving Shaving Soap Refill

What to consider before buying the best shaving soap for men? 

Price

While it is not an absolute fact, the price of your shaving soap could determine the quality that it has. Sometimes, the cheaper shaving soaps probably cost less because they lack the necessary ingredients to make such an effective soap.

Other inexpensive products are only disguised as shaving soaps, but they are nothing more than a simple bath soap. Many of these cheap soaps may not be offering you the appropriate amount of protection for your skin.

Presence of Glycerin and Tallow

One of the essential traits that should be present in a high-quality shaving soap is its high percentage of tallow and glycerin. Tallow is rendered fat that usually comes from cattle.

The presence of tallow in shaving soaps is essential because it protects and lubricates your skin while you shave. This way, when you glide the blade of your razor over your skin’s surface, your skin will not get irritated at all. Preferably, the level of fat should be at least 30 percent. 

On the other hand, glycerin is usually sourced from vegetables. It acts as a humectant. It traps in the water, thus moisturizing the skin. Moreover, glycerin serves as an emollient because it helps soften the beard while creating a barrier between your razor and moisturized skin.

Both glycerin and fat should be taken into consideration. The higher the percentage of these two, the batter the lather would be. The best way to gauge these two levels in the soap is that it coats the skin richly. Moreover, the shaving soap should lubricate without needing you to exert pressure.

Container

Many shaving soaps sold in the market come in a bowl. Many of the emerging brands, however, already come in a disc. For the latter, you will need to use a bowl or a mug.

Is it better to shave with soap, gel, or foam? 

One of the burning questions that may be in your is the best product to use when shaving. Will you be using soap, foam, or gel? Well, there are benefits and drawbacks to each of these products.

There are various reasons why each of these products is beneficial on each of its terms. Let us find out what these are.

Shaving soaps are primarily formulated to make a sound, lasting lather. This is because shaving soaps contain high levels of glycerin and fat.

We recommend using this instead of your regular soaps because they can leave your skin dry and inflamed. Shaving soaps are also efficient barriers. This allows water to retain in your skin, keeping your skin hydrated and well-moisturized.

The only drawback of using shaving soaps would be time since it can take you time to lather up using a shaving brush.

A shaving gel, on the other hand, comes in cans. A lot of people use shaving gels because they are suitable for shaping facial hair.

Aside from that, they help the razor blade to glide through your face smoothly. They act as efficient barriers, making them beneficial for those with sensitive skin. One of the drawbacks of using shaving gel is that it can clog your razor.

Finally, we have shaving foam. Shaving foams are very convenient because you can readily apply them to your face. They are very convenient to use. You simply have to shave the aerosol can, and then you can already use it. The only drawback is that they tend to dissipate quickly.

Now that you’ve read their benefits, we could now easily answer which among these three is the best. The simple answer is it depends on the product that works on your skin.

But for what it’s worth, we think that shaving soaps are the best ones because they are not only good for the skin, but they are also efficient in helping you shave. 

Closing Thoughts on the Top 9 Best Shaving Soap For Men 2023

When it comes to the best shaving soap for men, you have to be strategic about how you will be purchasing one. The reason behind this is that not all shaving soaps in the market offer the same consistency.

We recommend that you pick shaving soap of high quality so that you can shave off your beard without getting irritated. In terms of the products, we urge you to look into the different pros and cons of the best shaving soaps for sensitive skin.

This way, you will not get breakouts on your skin, and you will have a clean shave.